Lowbagger.org     

        "A voice in the cyberspace wilderness."                                              February 2005      



A Healthy-Sized Harvest


By Matt Koehler

 Forest monitoring on the Middle-East Fork.

As arctic air flows over the Continental Divide and descends into the broad valleys of western Montana, Northern Rockies forest activists’ are getting out on-the-ground to protect forests and wild places from the Bush Administration’s so-called Healthy Forest Initiative.

Of course, on-the-ground monitoring has always played an integral role in successful campaigns to protect national forests from logging and other forms of industrial resource extraction.

And anyone who has ever taken part in forest monitoring, which includes (among other things) walking in the woods, observing nature, looking for signs of wildlife, and taking photos, knows just how powerful of an experience it can be. Powerful in terms of overall effectiveness, but also in terms of how it impacts you as an individual.

It’s no secret that the Healthy Forest Initiative has drastically changed the way America’s national forests are managed, making it much easier for ecologically destructive logging and roadbuilding projects to move forward by limiting environmental analysis and public participation. Much more detailed information about the HFI is at www.nativeforest.org. 

Here in the Northern Rockies, forest activists are dealing with at least one hundred of the smaller logging projects that are being implemented under the new Categorical Exclusions rules that the Bush Administration put into effect as part of the HFI in 2003. 

Over the past year, we have monitored a number of these projects and have found some of them to include logging of old-growth, in unroaded areas and within important habitat for species such as lynx and goshawk.

Fortunately, the Forest Service has canceled a few of the more egregious timber sales because of our forest monitoring efforts – demonstrating again the importance of getting out in the woods! 

While the Forest Service has been busy in the Northern Rockies pushing these HFI logging projects under Categorical Exclusion, the agency is just getting started with HFI projects authorized under the Healthy Forests Restoration Act. 

The HFRA was signed into law during a White House ceremony on December 3, 2003 and without a doubt it was the part of the Bush Administration’s Healthy Forest Initiative that was put into place with the biggest fanfare.

While Northern Rockies forest activists support protecting communities from wildfire and putting people to work restoring our national forests, the HFRA has the potential to use community protection and forest restoration as a smokescreen for more logging in our public forests. This is especially true in national forests where the supervisor and district rangers still look at the forests in terms of board feet and two-by-fours. 

In Montana, the first HFRA project in the state is called the Middle East Fork Hazardous Fuel Reduction project on the Bitterroot National Forest. The proposed project, located along the East Fork of the Bitterroot River just downstream from the Anaconda Pintler Wilderness, would mix a small amount of bona-fide community protection work with logging over nine square miles of forest (6,000 acres in total), including clearcut logging in previously unlogged, old-growth forests.

Despite extensive logging and roadbuilding in East Fork drainage from the 1960s to late 1980s, the forest are home to bull trout, cutthroat trout, wolves, elk, moose, black bear, coyote, mule deer, goshawk, martin, black-backed woodpecker, pileated woodpecker and flammulated owls. 

Back in late November, a few days following an unproductive public meeting with Bitterroot National Forest officials about the Middle East Fork logging project – during which they seemed to have a difficult time speaking in anything but soundbites – forest activists decided it was time for a forest monitoring trip up the East Fork. After all, spending a day poking around in the woods is never a bad thing!

Since over 6,000 acres are slated for logging as part of this “Healthy Forest” project, we decided to focus our monitoring efforts on the logging units the Forest Service has proposed for “regeneration harvest.” 

For those unfamiliar with Forest Service vernacular, a “regeneration harvest” is a logging method that closely resembles a clearcut.  In fact, most people would not be able to tell the difference and during the public meeting Bitterroot National Forest officials fully admitted that only 3 or 4 trees per acre would be left within these “ regeneration harvests.” For a simple visualization exercise to get an idea of just what this would look like, imagine the football field with only 3 or 4 trees on it. Hardly a forest, right?

On that cold November morning, as we ascended an old logging road near Jennings Camp Creek and Colvert Creek within the Middle East Fork project area we could clearly see that many of the proposed logging units were right next to old clearcuts from either the 1960s or late 1980s. We thought out loud, “The very last thing this forest needs is more logging.” 

With the vehicle parked, lunch and water packed and maps, notebooks and cameras in hand we bushwhacked cross-country through unlogged, native forests that the Forest Service believes would be healthier if they were clearcut. 

As we dropped from the ridge into a small drainage within a “regeneration harvest” unit, we encountered massive Douglas-firs – first one-by-one…then whole groves. Although the Forest Service had described this area in largely negative terms during the public meeting – as a forest “destroyed” by insects and disease – the forest became more enchanting and magical with each step. 

Within this remarkable forest, our emotions ranged from honor and awe to anger and betrayal at the Forest Service for the callous and calculated approached some of them take “managing” our public forests. 

The Forest Service’s rationale for clearcutting this area, including cutting down the legacy Douglas-Fir trees, is that the trees are either infested with beetles or “at imminent risk of spread of the beetle epidemic.”

Of course, predictably, they are also playing the “fire hysteria” card by telling community members these forests need to be “thinned” to protect the community from wildfire. This, despite the fact that the Forest Service’s own research shows that effective home protection involves taking simple steps within 200 feet of homes. 

This is just the latest in a long line of Forest Service propaganda designed to stir up public fear about natural processes within our forests such as fire, insects, disease and windthrow.

While we found evidence of trees that had been killed by beetles, including old-growth Douglas-fir, the Forest Service is ignoring the fact that insect and disease mortality, even in “epidemic” proportions, is a natural and beneficial process that both forests and wildlife have evolved with for thousands of years.

Upon closer inspection, we noticed that seemingly mundane things such as a large Douglas-fir tree weakened by beetles, snapped in half by strong winds and lying on the forest floor is actually the perfect spot for squirrels to stash mushrooms and cones for the long winter months. Rabbits and other small mammals are drawn to these large, downed trees for the relative safety they provide from predators such as owls, hawks, lynx and coyote. And let’s not forget that these downed trees retain a tremendous amount of moisture and over the years, return important nutrients to the soil once they decay.

On a slope with a number of beetle-killed Douglas-fir we sat and listened to a half dozen woodpeckers hammering into the trees to feast on the nutritious beetles, the chorus reverberating around us in nature’s version of surround sound.

Call it the Circle of Life, Web of Life or whatever you want. The point is that life, death and rebirth – whether by fire, disease, insects, wind, predator/prey relationships or other natural processes – are, and always will be, an important part of naturally functioning ecosystems.

While some in the Forest Service might think they can make these forests “better than natural,” we’ll put our faith in nature’s ability every time.


Matthew Koehler is with the Native Forest Network. NFN is a Missoula-based nonprofit conservation organization dedicated to defending and restoring forests and wild places. Monitoring trips to the Bitterroot, and other threatened forests, are planned throughout the winter. 

For more information about the Middle East Fork Hazardous Fuel Reduction project visit http://www.nativeforest.org/middle_east_fork.htm or contact the Native Forest Network at nfn@wildrockies.org or 406.542.7343. 

As an alternative to the Forest Service’s logging plan for the East Fork of the Bitterroot, conservation groups have developed a “Community Protection and Local Economy Alternative.”  This plan protects old-growth forests while protecting communities from wildfire.  The plan also restores parts of the East Fork watershed that have been damaged by past logging and roadbuilding. 

You can also contact the Bitterroot National Forest directly to let them know how you feel about the Middle East Fork Hazardous Fuel Reduction project. Contact, Tracy Hollingshead, Sula Ranger District at thollingshead@fs.fed.us  or 7338 Hwy 93 S., Sula,  MT 59871 or email comments-northern-bitterroot-sula@fs.fed.us.

 

 

Lowbagger Home

Features

Grizzly Futures: The Bear vs. the Bush Administration
By Louisa Willcox

Season of the Buffalo
By Dan Brister


A Healthy-Sized Harvest
By Matt Koehler

Wilderness Study Area Assault
By Larry Campbell

Departments

Publisher's Notebook
Satan is My Co-Pilot
By Mike Roselle

Editor's Corner
What is Lowbagger.org? What is a lowbagger?

By Josh Mahan


On the Ground
Plutonium Wind Threatens Tetons
By Mary Woolen-Mitchell

Green Politics
Conservation and the Political Imperative
By Howie Wolke


National Affairs
No Friend of Mine
By Marilyn Olsen

Planet Watch
Major Free-Flowing River Faces Dams
By Bryce Smedley

School Zone
Short, Aggressive Manifesto on Education
By Shane Sanchez


Readings
Morning Light
Shorts and Ecology
By Tim Sandlin

Floogle Watch
The $11 Martini
By Uncle Ramon

Poet's Lounge
His Likable Ways, and Shock and Awe
By Greg Keeler

Mean Streets
By Phil Knight

Love is a Glove
By Derek Cook

Mountain Step
How to Lowbag a Peak
By John Fothergill

Conversations
At the Barbershop
By Peter Crumbaker

Fiction Focus
Coyote Goes Snowboarding
By Phil Knight